After deciding to formalize your business, one of the first big decisions is how to structure it. The choice affects your taxes, your personal liability and the paperwork you’ll keep up with every year. Two options come up more than any others: the limited liability company (LLC) and the S corporation.
Here’s the part that trips people up: these aren’t really two competing choices. An LLC is a legal entity you form under state law. An S corporation is a tax election you make with the IRS. A corporation can make that election, and so can an LLC. So the real question is usually twofold: which legal entity fits, and should it be taxed as an S corp?
What is an LLC?
An LLC combines the liability protection of a corporation with the simplicity and flexibility of a partnership. It’s often the starting point for new and small businesses.
- Taxation: By default, a single-member LLC is taxed like a sole proprietorship and a multi-member LLC like a partnership. Profits and losses flow through to the owners’ personal returns. An LLC can also elect to be taxed as an S corporation or a C corporation.
- Ownership: An LLC can have any number of owners (called members), including individuals, other companies and foreign owners.
- Self-employment tax: Unless the LLC elects corporate tax treatment, active members generally pay self-employment tax on their share of the profits.
- Formalities: LLCs generally have fewer formal requirements than corporations and more flexibility in how they’re managed.
What does the S corp election do?
An S corporation election lets a business pass its income, losses, deductions and credits through to its owners for federal tax purposes, so the business itself generally doesn’t pay federal income tax. The election is made on Form 2553.
- Salary and distributions: Owners who work in the business must be paid a reasonable salary through payroll. Profits taken beyond that as distributions aren’t subject to payroll tax, which is where the savings usually come from.
- Eligibility: An S corp can have no more than 100 shareholders, generally individuals who are U.S. citizens or residents, certain trusts and estates, and only one class of stock.
- Formalities: These depend on the legal entity underneath. A corporation keeps up corporate formalities such as board and shareholder meetings. An LLC that elects S status keeps its LLC structure, but now runs payroll and files a corporate tax return (Form 1120-S).
How to think about the choice
An LLC with default tax treatment often fits if:
- You’re just starting out, or profits are modest or uneven.
- You want the simplest structure and the fewest filings.
- You want flexibility in ownership and management.
Adding the S corp election often fits if:
- The business is consistently profitable enough that the payroll tax savings outweigh the added cost of payroll and a separate tax return.
- You can pay yourself a reasonable salary for the work you do.
- You meet the shareholder eligibility rules.
There’s no universal profit level where the election starts to make sense. It depends on your income, your state and what a reasonable salary looks like for your role, which is why we run the numbers rather than rely on a rule of thumb. Some states and cities also treat S corporations differently, so the state side deserves its own look.
How we help
- Evaluation: We look at your goals and projected income and recommend the structure and tax treatment that fit.
- Formation and elections: We form your LLC or corporation and file the S election when it makes sense.
- Planning: We help set a reasonable salary, set up payroll and revisit the numbers each year as the business grows.
- Ongoing compliance: Annual reports, tax filings and the other requirements that keep the business in good standing.
Where this leaves you
If you’re forming a business, or your LLC has grown and you’re wondering whether the S corp election now makes sense, it’s worth a conversation before year end. Reach out and we’ll look at your numbers.
Source: IRS: S corporations; IRS: Limited liability company (LLC)
This is general information, not tax advice for your specific situation. Reach out and we’ll look at your facts.